Your Source for Sports Cards
Collectibles and Memorabilia.

The Backstop is a collectible and hobby store located in Toms River, NJ. We buy and sell Sports Cards, Memorabilia, Non-Sports Cards, Supplies, Toys, Coins, Comic Books, Historical Items, Celebrity Items, Political items and more.

In addition to buying and selling we have a comprehensive appraisal service and authentication service (fees apply) so you know what your collection is worth for certain situations including Insurance Coverage, Divorce Settlements, Wills, Estate Sales and more. Use the form to get an online appraisal or make an appointment to bring your item(s) in or have us make a house call.

When you are in the area come visit us. Masks and social distancing is required.

Box Prices Change Daily

We carry a full line of supplies, display cases, new & vintage singles and signed memorabilia not listed on the inventory pages.  Call or stop in for more details.

BASEBALL INVENTORY
BASKETBALL INVENTORY
FOOTBALL INVENTORY
HOCKEY INVENTORY
ENTERTAINMENT INVENTORY
GAMING INVENTORY
MIXED & OTHER SPORTS
NONSPORTS INVENTORY
Current Inventory
Events
For Sellers

Contact The Backstop to Sell Your Items

sports cards & memorabilia store, BUYING & SELLING The Backstop, Toms River, NJ

Have Something to Sell?

We Buy and Sell:

  • Sports Cards
  • Non Sports Cards
  • Memorabilia
  • Collectibles

Need a Qualified Appraisal?

We appraise Sports Cards, Memorabilia, Toys, Coins, Comic Books, Historical Items, Celebrity Items, Political Items and more. Contact us for our fee schedule.

Sell Your Item(s)

The best way to sell your items is to bring it into our store.  If you can’t make it in use the form below to show us what you are selling.



    sports cards & memorabilia store, BUYING & SELLING The Backstop, Toms River, NJ
    sports cards & memorabilia store, BUYING & SELLING The Backstop, Toms River, NJ
    sports cards & memorabilia store, BUYING & SELLING The Backstop, Toms River, NJ
    sports cards & memorabilia store, BUYING & SELLING The Backstop, Toms River, NJ
    sports cards & memorabilia store, BUYING & SELLING The Backstop, Toms River, NJ
    sports cards & memorabilia store, BUYING & SELLING The Backstop, Toms River, NJ
    sports cards & memorabilia store, BUYING & SELLING The Backstop, Toms River, NJ

    Stay Connected with The Backstop

    Facebook
    Twitter
    Instagram
    Merchandise

    THE BACKSTOP MERCHANDISE

    Check out all of our “merch”.  From t-shirts to Mugs and more.

    Click Here to Check out our “Merch”